Premiere week is pretty much over, so I threw together a wrapup of some of the new shows, and which ones I'm hoping don't fall prey to the early-cancellation curse.
Ok, on to the shows.
The Good (basically in the order that I like them):
Pushing Daisies: Whimsical, dark, funny and insanely enchanting, "Pushing Daisies" is the story of a pie-maker with the power to bring the dead back to life. He touches them again, they're back to dead. And if they stay alive for more than a minute, someone else has to die in their place. This of course is complicated by the fact that his childhood sweetheart is murdered, and once he brings her back to life to find out who did it he can't bear to kill her again. With this plotline, "Pushing Daisies" pushes yearning and forbidden love to whole new levels. The cast is brilliant, and the style is something like Dr. Seuss meets Lemony Snicket meets Tim Burton meets Amelie. Fantastic.
Chuck: Take one nerd going nowhere, mix some government secrets into his brain, and throw in a beatiful CIA agent and a deadly NSA agent (played by the hero of Canton, the awesome Adam Baldwin) trying to protect those secrets, and you've got a formula for an action-packed, funny slice of a nerd's secret dream-life. Zachary Levi is adorable and charming as the awkward Chuck. I've heard the character described as a mixture of Seth Cohen and Jim Halpert, and that seems spot-on. With that kind of awesome-ness (and even a character named Captain Awesome), this show is a whole lot of fun.
Dirty Sexy Money: The deliciously scandalous Darling family springs off the screen as some combination of every awful, rich, entitled celebrity to ever hit the tabloids. Peter Krause is fantastic as their beleagered lawyer, who's mostly just trying to get to the bottom of his father's (the Darling's former lawyer) murder. From the corrupt clergyman to the excessively extravagant twins, the Darlings manage to be both horrifying and almost lovable. This one has "guilty pleasure" written all over it.
Reaper: Slacker Sam finds out on his 21st birthday that his parents sold his soul to the devil before he was born. Now the devil is back to collect, and makes Sam a bounty hunter for souls that have escaped from Hell. This show isn't perfect, but it's funny, charming and could have a whole lot of potential. Ray Wise is deliciously smooth as the devil, and as long as "Reaper" can avoid becoming too formulaic it's could be one of the most entertaining hours of TV this season.
The Decent:
Aliens in America: I didn't expect to like this pilot, but it was funny and felt very true-to-life. Some un-PC lines will surely be crossed in this show and that's kind of awesome. The premise is, basically, normal family gets exchange student to help their son make friends. Instead of the burly blond the hilariously ignorant mom envisioned, they get a Muslim student from Pakistan. While the son initially thinks his life is going to be even worse than before, and his mother freaks out entirely, he and the exchange student soon bond over their outsider status, and there's a lot of timely commentary on how we treat people we view as "different".
Gossip Girl: This is not the new "O.C." But the pilot had it's moments, and it's possible this could be the new guilty pleasure for those looking to fill the gap left by "The O.C."'s absence. I've always been a sucker for prime-time soaps, but this one just didn't hook me enough to make me a regular viewer. Maybe I've grown up since the adventures of Ryan Atwood hit the small screen, but "Gossip Girl" didn't appeal to me on the same level.
The Rest:
Carpoolers: This sitcom, about four guys who carpool to work together, had some laugh-out-loud moments, especially in the character of one of their sons, who is like a more grown-up Napolean Dynamite without pants. But so far, nothing special. Definitely not the revival of the sitcom.
Moonlight: I tend to love vampire shows, and this could suck me in. Alex O'Laughlin and Jason Dohring are both enticing, but Sophia Myles grates, and some of the creative choices (music especially) were seriously questionable. If this pulls itself together quickly it could be a guilty pleasure. Otherwise, I'll just watch my "Buffy" and "Angel" DVDs and wax nostalgic about the good ol' days.
Back to You: With such sitcom star power (Kelsey Grammer and Patricia Heaton, seriously), you'd think this show would have at least a glimmer of charisma. But no. Not very funny, and so far, none of the characters are very likeable. Barely a chuckle in the pilot, and I have no desire to watch more.
The Big Bang Theory: This one got a few laughs out of me, but the nerds are such incredibly stereotypical caricatures that it just rings false. And why does the "hot" girl have to be dumb and oblivious? Better than I'd anticipated based on commercials but still really not good.
I think that's pretty much it for the pilots I saw all the way through. The glimpses I saw of "Life" looked much more promising than I'd anticipated, and I've heard "Journeyman" has it moments. My attempt to watch "Bionic Woman" mostly bored me, with the exception of Katee Sackhoff's character.
Overall, not a bad crop of new shows. There are at least four that I'll give my attention to this season, and one or two others could make their way onto that list with some improvements.
Not that I need anymore TV shows.